It's not exactly the same, but for folks in the Triangle (Raleigh/Durham/Chapel Hill) area of NC, there is The Scrap Exchange[1].

[1]: https://www.scrapexchange.org/

Ax-Man Surplus in MN. https://www.ax-man.com/

I visited that place a couple of months ago, it was fantastic.

Halted was similar, but they're also gone :/

Oh, damn, I didn't realize they were gone. I used to like shopping there, but they started to seem less fun as time went on, and the last couple of times I went it seemed to have lost those positive/creative vibes.

This was always my go to, and a large source for movie-making:

https://apexsurplus.com/

Axman Surplus in MSP

Skycraft Surplus in Orlando: https://skycraftsurplus.com/

I was there last week (in town on business), and I found a Vector 3677-2 protoboard for $2!

The Reuseum in Garden City, ID

https://www.reuseum.com/

Bookmarking this, I can't believe I didn't know about this place when I lived there (although that was long enough ago they might not have been open).

Electronic Parts Outlet in Houston, TX

Jameco in Belmont, CA jameco.com

This is my Bay Area resource for electronic parts in a pinch.

I hate how few responses there are to this.